Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Clinical and Diagnostic Laboratory Immunology, January 2004, p. 89-93, Vol. 11, No. 1
1071-412X/04/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/CDLI.11.1.89-93.2004
Copyright © 2004, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Nekeidra Brown,1,
Patricia Holder,1 Thomas Hennessy,2 Patricia Gomez de Leon,3 and George M. Carlone1
Division of Bacterial and Mycotic Diseases, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia,1 Arctic Investigations Program, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Anchorage, Alaska,2 School of Medicine, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City, Mexico3
Received 15 September 2003/ Returned for modification 3 November 2003/ Accepted 7 November 2003
|
|
|---|
50% killing as the SBA titer end point), and titers were not significantly different when compared to those of the standard assay (P > 0.68). However, the fluorometric end point had superior performance and ease of titer determination compared to the colorimetric end point (95 versus 87% of SBA titers were within 2 dilutions of the standard titer). Hib SBA assays with alamarBlue are reproducible, faster (same-day assay), and easier to perform than the standardized assay, which requires manual or automated colony counts. These semiautomated methodologies result in increased sample throughput and collection of data in digital formats that can be exported to data analysis programs for determination of SBA titers. |
|
|---|
Immunological evaluation of vaccine-induced protection includes the measurement of vaccine-induced antibodies by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Minimal levels for short-term protection (as determined for unconjugated polysaccharide vaccines) are
0.15 µg/ml, and for long-term protection they are
1.0 µg/ml (5, 8). Antibody function is measured by serum bactericidal activity (SBA) rather than by ELISA. The current SBA assay relies on the measurement of Hib viability after addition of active complement and serum antibodies (12). This method is highly reproducible, but it requires overnight incubation to allow for the formation of CFU, it has a lower sample throughput, and it requires either manual or automated counting of CFU for the determination of SBA titers. In addition, data analysis is time-consuming, as the interface with data analysis programs is not automated. In this study, we evaluated a metabolic indicator (alamarBlue) to develop both a colorimetric and a fluorometric SBA assay for Hib, which is a highly fastidious organism. Mountzouros and Howell used this type of indicator for SBA assays specific for Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B (11). In this study, we determined that alamarBlue is suitable for same-day SBA titer determinations (fluorometric end point), it is highly reproducible, and it allows for automated data collection.
|
|
|---|
Standard SBA assay.
We performed the standardized SBA assay, which measures the direct bactericidal activity of serum antibodies as previously described by Romero-Steiner et al. (12), which is a modification of the method described by Schlesinger et al. (13). This assay was used as the standard method for comparison of SBA titers generated by the assays containing alamarBlue. Specifically, serum samples were tested in duplicate at a starting dilution of 1:8. Twofold serum serial dilutions were made in 10 µl of Hanks buffer with Ca2+ and Mg2+ (Life Technologies, Grand Island, N.Y.) supplemented with 2% Fildes enrichment (BBL, Becton Dickinson and Co., Sparks, Md.). A frozen aliquot of Hib strain GB 3292 (12) was diluted to yield 1,000 bacteria in a 20-µl volume (amount added to each well). An active source of complement was added after a preincubation period of 15 min at 37°C and 5% CO2. The complement used (25 µl per well) was sterile serum from 3- to 4-week-old baby rabbits (Pel-Freez, Brown Deer, Wis.), previously used as an efficient source of complement in Hib SBA assays (12, 14). An additional 25 µl of the dilution buffer as described above was added to each well. The final volume per well was 80 µl. After an incubation of 1 h at 37°C in 5% CO2, an aliquot of 5 µl from each well was plated onto chocolate agar plates (ChocII; BBL) and allowed to incubate at 37°C in 5% CO2 for 16 h. Viability counts of CFU were performed on each individual serum dilution, and SBA titers were determined. SBA titers were defined as the reciprocal of the serum dilution that resulted in
50% killing compared to the growth in complement controls. The predetermined SBA titer of 4,096 ± 1 dilution was consistently obtained with the PSAB-90 serum control.
alamarBlue SBA. alamarBlue (Trek Diagnostics, Westlake, Ohio) is a patented (9) metabolic indicator that is commercially available. This metabolic indicator is not toxic or inhibitory to Hib. In its oxidized form alamarBlue is blue, and when it is reduced by the bacterium it changes to a pink compound. The amount of reduced alamarBlue can be measured in a spectrophotometer at 490 nm, under the assay conditions described for a colorimetric SBA assay. The reduced compound is also fluorescent (emission wavelength = 590 nm) if excited by a UV light source at a wavelength of 530 nm for a fluorometric SBA assay. The amount of reduced alamarBlue is proportional to cell growth, which in an SBA assay is directly proportional to the number of Hib bacteria surviving serum bactericidal killing.
For the alamarBlue SBA assays, the same protocol described for the standard SBA assay was followed, except that 25 µl of an alamarBlue buffer was added to each well after the addition of complement. The alamarBlue buffer included 16% alamarBlue, 64% Hanks buffer (containing Ca2+ and Mg2+ and 2% Fildes enrichment) and 20% brain heart infusion (BHI) broth (BBL). Typically, alamarBlue was diluted daily, as described, in a 10-ml volume and kept in the dark until used. BHI broth was needed to increase the growth of the surviving bacteria. This allowed for a fluorometric endpoint determination the same day as the assay performance. Incubation time for the fluorometric assay was 6 h at 37°C and 5% CO2. After the 6-h incubation period, assay plates were read in a fluorometer (model FL 600; BIO-TEK Instruments Inc., Winooski, Vt.). However, plates were allowed to incubate for a total of 19 to 22 h and read in a spectrophotometer (model ELX808; BIO-TEK) in order to read the colorimetric end point. Since the alamarBlue SBA assay required absorbance and fluorescence readings, reagent blanks were included in all plates. These blanks contained all assay reagents except bacteria. Similar to the standardized SBA assay, serum dilution titers were compared to complement control wells. These wells contained all assay reagents including bacteria and complement source but did not contain immune sera.
In order to obtain SBA titers similar to those of the standard SBA assay, the SBA titers for the colorimetric assay were defined as the reciprocal of the serum dilution at the inflection point of the bactericidal curve. This inflection point corresponded to the serum dilution prior to the plateau of each serum's absorbance curve. This plateau was defined as the serum dilution where the bacterial growth was in the same range as the absorbance observed in the complement controls (mean optical density at 490 nm [OD490] ± SD = 0.37 ± 0.08). SBA titers for the fluorometric assay were defined, following the same format as the standard SBA assay, as the reciprocal of the serum dilution with
50% of the fluorescent units (FU) detected in the complement controls. Regardless of the end point, the SBA assay using alamarBlue is an indirect method for the measurement of metabolism of the surviving bacteria after SBA.
Statistical analysis.
Correlations between SBA assays were determined by Pearson's product moment correlation coefficient by use of Sigma Plot software, version 8.0 (SPSS, Inc., Chicago, Ill.). Significant differences among assays were determined by Student's t test or the Mann-Whitney rank sum test for data not normally distributed. Comparisons between paired data were done by chi-square or Fisher's two-tailed exact test, using EpiInfo software version 6 (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [CDC], Atlanta, Ga.). The significance level was set at a P value of <0.05. All SBA titers were determined as discontinuous titers. Percent agreements between standard and test (alamarBlue) SBA titers were calculated for SBA titers at >8 (a/a+c) or
8 (d/b+d) using two-by-two tables, where a is the number of sera reported as >8 by both assays, b is the number of sera reported as
8 by the standard assay but >8 by the test assay, c is the number of sera reported as >8 by the standard assay but
8 by the test assay, and d is the number of sera reported as
8 by both assays.
|
|
|---|
Reproducibility of Hib SBA assays containing alamarBlue. The reproducibility of both the colorimetric and the fluorometric assays was evaluated using the quality control serum PSAB-90, as shown in Fig. 1. For this control serum, the range (mean ± SD) of absorbance measured at 490 nm was 0.4 ± 0.14 to 0.07 ± 0.05 (Fig. 1A). The overall mean OD ± SD values for reagent blanks, complement control, and blanked complement control wells were 0.20 ± 0.07, 0.58 ± 0.08, and 0.37 ± 0.08, respectively. The coefficients of variance for reagent blanks, complement control, and blanked complement control wells were 35, 13.8, and 22%, respectively. The colorimetric SBA assay had a very restricted curve range. This narrow range made the interpretation of the SBA titers more difficult than in the fluorometric SBA assay. The range (mean ± SD) of the fluorometric SBA assay measured at 6 h under the conditions described was from 19,985 ± 3,221 FU for complement controls to 3,106 ± 525 FU for reagent blanks. The coefficients of variance for complement controls and reagent blanks were 16.1 and 16.9, respectively, with the fluorometric end point. Figure 1B gives the fluorescence signals observed for PSAB-90. In the fluorometric SBA assay, data were not blanked, since there was a high signal-to-noise ratio (6.4). In both alamarBlue SBA assays, the calculated median titer for PSAB-90 was 2,048 ± 1 dilution. This median titer was 1 dilution lower than the median titer observed with the standard SBA assay. The minimal level of quantification was a titer of 8 for the standard SBA assay as well as for the alamarBlue SBA assays. A titer lower than 8 was assigned a titer of 4 to allow for statistical analysis. Table 1 gives the standard SBA colony counts (CFU) that corresponded to the colorimetric and fluorometric SBA end points after a 6-h and a 19-h incubation period for the control serum, PSAB-90.
![]() View larger version (14K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Serum bactericidal dilution curve for the serum control, PSAB-90, read under colorimetric optimal conditions (A) and under fluorometric optimal conditions (B). The arrow in panel A shows the inflection point in the SBA assay absorbance curve used to define the SBA titer compared to that in corresponding complement control wells. The dashed line in panel B indicates the 50% threshold used to define the SBA titer compared to that in complement control wells.
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Comparison of a Hib standard SBA assay with fluorometric and colorimetric end points of an SBA assay using alamarBlue
|
3 dilutions from the standard SBA assay.
![]() View larger version (21K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Comparison of SBA titers (n = 40 human serum samples) obtained by either the colorimetric SBA (A) or the fluorometric SBA (B) with the standard SBA. The dotted line represents the identity line, and the solid line represents the regression line. Correlation coefficients were determined by Pearson's product moment correlation coefficient. The percent agreement between the standard SBA and the colorimetric end point for titers of >8 was 97%, and for titers of 8 it was 50%. Similarly, the percent agreement for fluorometric titers of >8 was 100%, and for titers of 8 it was 83%.
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Cumulative percentage of serum samples within a given dilution difference compared to that with the standard SBA assay
|
|
|
|---|
AlamarBlue is blue in its oxidized form. When reduced by bacteria or tissue culture cells, it changes to a bright pink color that can be measured at 570 nm in the visible range or in the fluorometric UV range at 590 nm. The oxidized blue state can only be read at 600 to 630 nm in the visible range, and it is not fluorometric. Under the Hib SBA assay conditions (buffers are dark amber in color), the oxidized state was green instead of blue and the optimal wavelength for measurement of the reduced pink state was 490 nm. Other wavelengths tested were 405, 450, 562, and 620 nm (data not shown).
Use of alamarBlue in Hib SBA assays was found to be simple and practical for the measurement of SBA specific to Hib. However, improved assay performance was found (Fig. 2B) with the fluorometric readout (530/590 nm [excitation/emission UV wavelength]). The use of alamarBlue in Hib SBA assays offers a number of advantages over the standard SBA assay, such as (i) rapid instrument collection of results (40 to 60 s per 96-well plate), (ii) interface to computer software, (iii) 1-day assay for the fluorometric end point, (iv) potential for higher throughput of serum samples, (v) use of instruments available in most laboratory settings, and (vi) elimination of manual or automated viability counts and consequently the use of agar plates (ChocII). The main disadvantages of using alamarBlue in Hib SBA assays were observed for the colorimetric end point rather than the fluorometric end point. These disadvantages were (i) high sensitivity to buffer conditions, especially for the colorimetric end point; (ii) incubation times require close monitoring for the fluorometric assay (6 h ± 30 min); (iii) SBA titer determination in the colorimetric assay is difficult and may require plotting the SBA curve or a data analysis program to avoid subjectivity; and (iv) a narrow absorbance range for the colorimetric endpoint (blanked OD490 range, 0.07 to 0.4).
In the evaluation of alamarBlue as a metabolic indicator of SBA activity for Hib, we found this compound to be highly stable under the SBA assay conditions and under the recommended storage conditions (4°C in the dark until expiration date). This compound was not toxic to Hib and did not result in bacterial cell death in the absence of anti-polyribosylribitol phosphate antibodies. Bacterial viability counts were identical in the presence or absence of alamarBlue after a 1-h incubation period (data not shown).
Due to its superior performance, we recommend the fluorometric over the colorimetric SBA assay for the measurement of Hib SBA titers. SBA titers can be determined the same day as assay performance. Although the fluorometric end point requires a fluorometer, the SBA titers were easily defined and highly comparable to the standard SBA titers. We are currently evaluating the use of this metabolic indicator for meningococcal SBA (serogroups A, C, Y, and W135). The use of alamarBlue in measuring Hib SBA should facilitate broader application of this immunological assay for the evaluation of Hib vaccines.
The findings of this research do not represent any endorsement of any commercial product by the CDC. The investigators do not have any conflict of interest with the manufacturers of the reagent evaluated in this study.
Present address: Department of Pulmonary Medicine, Emory University, Atlanta, GA 30322. ![]()
Present address: College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences, Texas Southern University, Houston, TX 77288. ![]()
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2010 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»